He replaces Dave Lewis, who announced his shock departure a year ago.
Lewis had said the decision to step down was “a personal one” and that he believed “the tenure of the CEO should be finite”.
The idea had already been floated behind closed doors, and in fact, the board immediately announced the appointment of Murphy, poached from the role of chief commercial officer and president of global brands at Walgreens Boots Alliance.
Murphy has big shoes to fill after Lewis turned Tesco around, led a corporate restructuring and rebuilt the balance sheet.
“Whereas Mr Lewis faced into a tsunami of internal challenge, he passes a leadership ‘ball’ onto his successor at the right pace, direction and height,” noted analysts at Shore Capital.
“Whilst this is so, it would be incorrect to suggest that Mr Murphy does not face challenges.
“His issues, however, are largely external, now that Tesco is a well-oiled operating machine and considerably more solvent, something that should be notably enhanced assuming that the Asia disposal completes before Christmas 2020”.
If anything, what Murphy is about to face is not unique to Tesco but a case of shared woes across the retail sector notable the economic recession, the coronavirus crisis and fragile UK-EU relations.
Looking at the internal strategy, the market wonders when Tesco Bank can be offloaded, whether the Aldi price match is sustainable and how retail underlying margins can be protected with the move to online.
Shareholders are not keen on the bank, which is expected to swing to a full-year loss of between GBP175-200mln from last year’s profit of GBP193mln due to potentially higher bad debts amid a drop in global GDP.
“There’s a lot of capital tied up in the bank and it only delivers modest upstream benefits to the parent company,” fund manager Richard Buxton, of Tesco shareholder Jupiter, told the Evening Standard.
“The regulatory burden and oversight that’s needed with owning a bank is huge. It would be better that a traditional bank owned it and Tesco supplied the customers.”
UBS said the ‘Big 4’ supermarket is benefitting from the increase in online penetration in the UK market accelerated by the COVID-19 crisis, which is leaving discounters behind due to the operational challenges of establishing an e-commerce platform.
“In the short-term, the strong customer metrics, sustained sales growth and substantially lower COVID-19 costs point to upside risks to full-year estimates, while the approval of the Asian deal in October or November should return GBP5bn to investors in the second half.”
A new board
Murphy will also be leading the FTSE 100 company in the absence of Charles Wilson, managing director of Booker “but also one of the industry’s true leaders”, according to Shore Capital, who is set to leave Tesco by the end of February 2021 and will be replaced by Andrew Yaxley.
Chief financial officer Alan Stewart is also due to leave no later than April 2021 but no successor has been selected yet.
“Mr Lewis has left the business with it in good shape, with a 51p special dividend and enhanced solvency, particularly around the pension responsibilities, to come,” Shore Capital concluded.
“The grocery retail sector market opportunity is enhanced by social change, notably working from home, and Tesco has seized the online food opportunity well; doubling capacity in a capital-light manner and seeing the channel turn to profit.”
Shares in Tesco were trading 1% lower at 211.19p on Thursday afternoon, the same level of March lows after a rollercoaster few months, including a peak of 248p in May.